PRESIDENTIAL DINNERS. EVERYDAY GROCERIES.
POTUSPLATEHISTORY • RECIPES • YOUR DINNER

A recorded dinner and a surviving recipe

Why this dinner?

February 1802 · The President’s House, Washington

Manasseh Cutler recorded macaroni at a dinner in Jefferson’s President’s House in February 1802. He mistook its contents for something like onions and did not much enjoy it. That is a better historical detail than the familiar claim that Jefferson invented macaroni and cheese. He did not.

Monticello preserves the evidence for Jefferson’s interest in pasta, including his notes and the dinner account. It also documents his handwritten ice-cream recipe. Here we use those two connections for a smaller meal: baked macaroni as the main dish, peas for a fresh side, and ice cream made before dinner day. The sauce, cheese blend and portions are adjusted for a modern home kitchen.

What the record supports

The macaroni dinner is documented. The ice cream has a separate manuscript basis. Peas are our accompaniment; this is a selected home menu, not a transcription of all the dishes Cutler ate.

See the historical sources